Tuckman's stages of group development
- Forming: Team members first meet, learn their roles and responsibilities, and are cautious with their behavior as they try to assimilate with the group.
- Storming: Tensions rise as team members start to speak their minds and solidify their places within the group.
- Norming: Conflicts start to resolve, team members appreciate each other’s strengths, and respect for authority grows.
- Performing: The group functions together as a cohesive unit and without as much direction from the team leader.
- Adjourning: The original goals of the team have been completed, and everyone can move on to new projects.
Think back to your high school days when you were assigned a group project in one of your classes. You were given a task to complete and then challenged to complete that task with other people (one of whom was definitely going to slack off and let the rest of the group handle the entire project). So many issues arose when the team started working together, and it seemed more trouble to function as a unit than as an individual.
That arrangement, with all its frustrations and triumphs, resembles the way teams function in business. In the worst cases, business teams can be as dysfunctional as miscreant teenagers, but in the best cases, they can go on to produce some of the most revolutionary ideas and world-changing products.
So how can you set your team up for the best case scenario?
In 1965, Dr. Bruce Tuckman published the Tuckman model, in which he detailed the stages of team development. Whether you are a manager or are simply one of the team, once you understand these stages of group development, you can help your group push past challenges and become a high-performing unit.
What are the stages of team formation?
Dr. Tuckman identified four (and later, five) stages of group development:
Each stage has its own characteristics and challenges ranging from the emotional to the logistical. Review what you can expect from each stage of team development.
The forming stage is marked by a mix of anxiety and hesitation (and potentially excitement for the work ahead). After all, this is the stage at which your team will first meet each other—they’ll be given a task and then faced with completing that task with near-perfect strangers.
During this stage, team members will be cautious with their behavior as they try to assimilate with the group. The real personalities of the team won’t be revealed until later; in the beginning, getting along with the rest of the team members is of primary importance.
Along with learning more about their colleagues, team members are also introduced to their roles and responsibilities. Managers or team leaders should help establish what the team is trying to accomplish and how they will work together. Typical outcomes are likely to include:
- An overview of the team’s purpose
- A review of team organization and accompanying responsibilities
- A rough project outline and schedules
- General group rules (how the team should communicate and how often they should meet)
- An investigation of available resources
Team leaders may want to use visuals, such as swimlane diagrams and process flows, with everyone’s roles and responsibilities clearly outlined. Such visuals can be easily distributed to the group and can prevent arguments and confusion.
Once the group members become more familiar with one another, the next stage of group development begins.
This stage is aptly named, as it is here that tensions first arise. The storming stage is marked by competition and conflict. Here, team members are starting to speak their minds and solidifying their places within the group, which means that power struggles may arise and cliques may form within the group. And, if team members don’t feel their responsibilities are clearly defined by this point, they may feel overwhelmed and stressed.
In order to withstand the storming stage, it’s important for the team to remain focused on its goals and desired outcomes. Otherwise, the group is likely to become mired in relationships and emotional issues and never progress to completing the actual task.
If you’re a manager, you can help the storming stage resolve and progress by negotiating compromises among team members. Compromising during the storming stage resolves conflict and pushes the team to forward. Facilitate team discussions and remind team members to be respectful of others’ opinions and comments.
If you’ve visualized team hierarchy and processes during the forming stage, you can use those visuals to reiterate how team members should be working together.
The norming stage is the quiet after the storm. During this stage, conflicts start to resolve, team members appreciate each other’s strengths, and respect for authority grows. Team members are also less dependent on the team leader to provide direction and make decisions—they start working together and helping each other to achieve the team’s goals.
It’s important to note that, since you’re dealing with humans, there’s no way to fast-forward to this stage because your team needs time to become comfortable with each other. Trust takes time, and often bonds arise out of conflict, so the storming stage is actually necessary to develop the kind of cohesiveness that propels successful groups forward.
The group development stages aren’t as linear as they appear on paper. After all, it’s not like the group shows up to the office one day and decides unanimously to peacefully progress to the norming stage. Sometimes your group may revert back to behavior from the storming stage. Sometimes there’s overlap between the storming and norming stage. And sometimes the storming stage seems to last for much longer than is necessary. Keep to the project’s timeline and keep referring to the organizational tools you’ve developed.
This is where the real alchemy happens. At the performing stage, the group is functioning together as a cohesive unit. The team has a shared vision and can function without the leader’s interference. It’s here that the group has learned how to resolve conflicts when they arise, and if changes need to occur, they’re implemented well. Structures and processes are now second nature.
As a team manager, you can delegate your work without having to micromanage its completion. This stage is more about fine-tuning and development.
What’s this—a fifth stage?
In 1975, Bruce Tuckman added a fifth stage to his Forming Storming Norming Performing model. Adjourning is the natural break-up of the group. This stage occurs when the original task of the group is completed and everyone can move on to new goals.
This fifth stage gives rise to a kind of mourning. By this time, the group has worked closely with one another and has developed relationships; it’s natural for feelings of insecurity to arise and for some to even feel threatened by the change.
As a team leader, it’s your job to help the group navigate through these insecurities and emotions and prepare for the next group formation and leadership successor. No matter what, it’s important to celebrate the team’s achievements and give them the opportunity to say good-bye to each other.
As a manager, you’re now familiar with the 5 stages of group development, but your team likely isn’t.
Prepare your team for each stage, and use tools like Lucidchart to outline their roles and responsibilities throughout the journey. Keeping visual guidelines throughout the process is vital for maintaining the integrity of your team and avoiding conflict and confusion. Since Lucidchart is a cloud-based platform, you can easily update the progress of your project as it changes so everyone stays on the same page.
The best groups have an innate understanding of their processes and structure, but that innate understanding only comes after the processes and structure have been articulated. Lucidchart is the perfect solution, as flowcharts and other visuals are easily understood and can be immediately accessed by anyone in your group.
It’s one thing to be given a task and quite another to get a group to successfully complete that task. However, the stages of group development can show you how to navigate the dynamics of group projects, so you can successfully guide your team to becoming an autonomous, functional unit that produces beautiful work.
Lucidchart, a cloud-based intelligent diagramming application, is a core component of Lucid Software's Visual Collaboration Suite. This intuitive, cloud-based solution empowers teams to collaborate in real-time to build flowcharts, mockups, UML diagrams, customer journey maps, and more. Lucidchart propels teams forward to build the future faster. Lucid is proud to serve top businesses around the world, including customers such as Google, GE, and NBC Universal, and 99% of the Fortune 500. Lucid partners with industry leaders, including Google, Atlassian, and Microsoft. Since its founding, Lucid has received numerous awards for its products, business, and workplace culture. For more information, visit lucidchart.com.
6 ways to optimize team communication on long-term projects
Did you know that small businesses spend around 17 hours a week just clarifying communication? Learn how you can get your team in sync and increase productivity—Ryan Gould from Elevation Marketing shares six tips for improving team communication today.
[Flowchart] Which communication style are you working with?
If you've ever experienced miscommunication in the workplace (and who hasn't?), it might be because your colleagues use different types of communication styles. Learn your colleagues' styles with our handy flowchart—and then find tips to communicate more clearly with them.